@inhisservice3320 Sorry I wasn't clear - I was commenting about each name needing to be unique.
I'm not saying that super short BC names were puppy mill type names but was commenting on the 3 situations (BCs, PAL registrations and puppy mills/BYBs) I've seen repeated short names, typically followed by a number. I should have been more clear that each of those is clearly separate and have no overlap.
I was basically referring to this rule:
The AKC permits thirty-seven (37) dogs of each breed to be assigned the same name.
This rule came about partly due to "Lassie" in (Rough/Smooth) Collies. From the beginnings of the AKC, many thousands of Collies have been registered just as "Lassie" and AKC found it unmanageable. And so the name "Lassie" has been retired for Collies and no Collie can be registered as Lassie. Lassie can be used as part of a longer name (one of my Zeffie's relatives was "Hilltops Sweet and Sassy Lassie") but not simply Lassie.
In many breeds names have been "used up" and retired. They don't have to be breed specific like "Lassie" in collies (or Pongo in Dalmatians, Lady in Cocker Spaniels, and so on). All popular pet names - King, Max, Princess, etc. - got used up.
Border collies are interesting since there's such a strong tradition of one word, no-nonsense names and they have their own registry. IIRC dogs who were originally registered with a different registry must keep their registered names. I know that's the way it works with FCI and CKC registries and think it's the same with the ABCA. Anyway, BCs have their own unique situation and there's a lot more repeats beyond 37. I wonder how many BCs with the names of "Meg", "Nop" or "Roy" have been registered.
Four years ago, I actually checked for the fun of it, if "Alfie" was available in Collies (IIRC only 18 had been registered so it was). I joked about just registering our Alfie as simply "Alfie". Unlike with Border Collies, in Rough/Smooth Collie land, the norm is for registered names to be complex, often relating to parentage/theme and to always include the kennel names (such as, from Alfie's pedigree: Bo-Dandy Rock Solid who sired Mandalay Rock and Roll). Since Alfie was going to be shown in the breed ring, having a simple registered name like "Alfie" would have be seen as weird, but worse, as a big insult to his breeders.
Anyway, sorry for being confusing. BTW, "Lift" is an awesome name for a BC.
![Smile :) :)]()