@randywmoore45 I used it in place of kibble every 6-8 instances of good behavior. We use "nice" as our marker for good behavior, so an example of using the tube to reinforce would look like this:
- Dog heels (her shoulder to my knee) for 2-3 steps
- Mark behavior with "nice" and come to stop
- Gently (this is key) squeeze some training paste into their mouths. They'll lick/bite the tube but I remove it as soon as I see they've gotten some paste.
- Give cue to resume walking
- Repeat as often/infrequently as you and your dog need!
I also have been using it outside of heel-training to work on socialization--because it's so high value, I can keep it at the dog's mouth for several seconds and it's engaging enough that I can keep her focus on me (even if I'm not actively squeezing the tube).
The first few times we used it, they were a bit skeptical, but by the middle of the first walk (about 10 minutes in) both were doing really well walking with a loose leash. I think they were caught off guard by the texture and method of delivery, but once we all practiced it became a really smooth method of treating. I keep the squeeze bottle in my pocket when I'm not using it--I only remove it and open the lid
after I mark the behavior. I don't want the sound of the lid opening to become a cue for them. Let me know if you have any other questions!